Skip to main content

The Economics of Vintage Luxury: The Wristwatch Phenomenon

“After the electric light goes into general use, none but the extravagant will burn tallow candles.”

This prophetic proclamation by American inventor and businessman Thomas Edison, printed by the New York Herald on January 4, 1880, aptly characterizes the modern market for mechanical and automatic watches, which serve today as extravagant showcases of wealth, or pretense thereof.

Just as with the tallow candles of old, the mechanical watch returns its wearer to a treasured past, full of sacred ideals and aspirational grandeur.

A great many, however, confuse the end retail price for an expression of quality, rather than one reflective of the voracious demand for recapturing the former.

This is the very subject of this writing, to disentangle fact from fiction, and to expose the real causes of the costs incurred.

Despite the illogical rumblings of the luxury watch community, the retail price is dictated not by intrinsic or utility value, nor exclusively by the cost of production, but by factors of exclusivity and collectibility; these markets do not necessarily follow quality.

What's more, quartz clocks (electronic oscillators) are vastly more accurate and more reliable than mechanical movements.

The latter survives only for its collectibility and appeal to tradition.

While one can certainly appreciate the value of detailed craftsmanship and quality control, these are two incontrovertible characteristics of a $300 Seiko and a time-tested, timelessly-appropriate Casio F91W-1, which is currently priced under $12 per unit.

How, then, can anyone possibly justify the purchase of an $8,000 Rolex Submariner? The answer, of course, is found in the brand's cachet, its prestige and recognizability, and the sordid sense of superiority engendered in its wearers.

While elegance and luxury can beautify the experience of life, one must satisfy due diligence to ascertain the value of any good, to better understand the value-add and attending costs.

Upon the completion of this investigation, one will invariably arrive at the conclusion that their value stems not from their quality, functionality or reliability relative to today's superior counterparts, but rather from their (often-induced) rarity and collectibility, a function of assigned sentimental value derived from one's aspired connection with memories and ideals attached to a bygone era.

The only measure against which the mechanical (or automatic) movement surpasses the quartz counterpart is through the refined and intricate processes required to craft and maintain the former.

However, just as with a vintage BMW or high-end luxury car, they are not naturally rendered any more valuable because of this liability; indeed, this is precisely the cause for such precipitous depreciation in the used luxury auto market.

What's more, value stems not from the quantity or quality of labor required to produce the end products, but rather from the subjective valuations of competing consumers who effectively demand them.

This is known in economics as the subjective theory of value, the school of thought which replaced the labor theory of value which underlies the comments of typical brand loyalists.

Take the 1913 Ford Model T, for example, each of which took two and a half hours to assemble, and compare it to the modern Ford factory that can assemble more than 1,000 cars per day.

The Model T is an inferior automobile in nearly every capacity, except for its collectibility in a narrow subsegment of the market.

The same can be stated for boutique automakers today, such as Pagani and Koenigsegg, whose low-volume (and largely in-house) production lines induce scarcity and unique styling cues to fetch millions of dollars (USD) for vehicles whose prices are justified by their exclusivity or their heritage, not by their functionality or reliability.

Indeed, these vehicles are notoriously expensive to maintain and repair, and their performance specifications match those of supercar competitors whose models are priced millions of dollars lower.

Consider a 1968 Oldsmobile 442 priced today at $37,000. The modern entry-level Camaro is quicker 0-60 MPH, faster in the quarter-mile, far more fuel efficient, corners better, handles better on snow and ice, comes with a manufacturer's warranty, and offers a myriad resplendent features and interior comforts, for a price of $25,000, 32 percent less than the vintage 442. Oddly, the 442 originally sold at $3,000, meaning today's asking price exceeds the original (inflation-adjusted) MSRP by more than 60 percent. The same factors influence the luxury watch market, and the majority of all luxury markets for that matter.

So long as one understands the constitution of the price, one can make a reasoned decision, hopefully to fulfill a personal desire irrespective of the impulse to impress others.

Remember, these items are highly unlikely to make your life any better or easier, to make you any better as a person.

Ultimately, it's far more important to preserve wealth than to project it.


Popular posts from this blog

America's Civil War: Not "Civil" and Not About Slavery

Virtually the entirety of South and Central America, as well as European powers Britain, Spain and France, peacefully abolished slavery — without war — in the first sixty years of the nineteenth century. 

Why, then, did the United States enter into a bloody war that cost over half of the nation’s wealth, at least 800,000 lives and many hundreds of thousands more in casualties? 

The answer: the War Between the States was not about slavery. 

It was a war of invasion to further empower the central government and to reject state sovereignty, nullification of unconstitutional laws, and the states’ rights to secession. 

It was a war that would cripple the South and witness the federal debt skyrocket from $65 million in 1860 to $2.7 billion in 1865, whose annual interest alone would prove twice as expensive as the entire federal budget from 1860.

It was a war that would blur the lines and jurisdictions between sovereign states, that would indiscriminately sacrifice the founding principles etched …

The Evils of Facebook in the War Against Reason

Facebook is one of the greatest frauds whereby thoughtless friends share or tacitly embrace ideas which, in doing so, adds personal, relatable flair to messages being distributed from largely unknown reporters. 

In effect, these friends then subject a wider community to the thought that since their friends are supportive of such ideas, then they ought to carry some merit or authenticity. 

Facebook commits a great disservice to communication, serving primarily to subject meaningful dialogue to inherently-binary measures of laudability or contemptibility. 

Whereas scientific evaluation serves to extract emotion, Facebook serves to embolden the fallacy-ridden supposition that fact follows fanfare, that truth trails trendiness, and that democratic participation (by way of “likes” or “shares”) can reliably support truth or sustainably produce virtue.

What's more, Facebook and other social media sites tend also to further the fallacy that the last breath, or more precisely the final keystro…

One of Every Three American Adults is a Criminal

Earlier today, the Wall Street Journal posted an article on the growing epidemic of criminal records. The article reports that nearly one out of every three American adults has a criminal record — a statistic corroborated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, whose records show 77.7 million individuals on file in the organization's master criminal database. Is this an indication of a society which is becoming more violent and criminal, or of one which is becoming ever-populated with needless and overreaching laws, ordinances, and regulations? In a country whose growing majority depends upon government for salary or entitlements, this is indeed the mechanism through which the dependency is enabled. Some are apparently more than willing to surrender increments of freedom for the promise of free stuff.    

Along with the extensive and pervasive development of laws in the United States, their execution has become more vile and horrid; and the experience of police brutality, along wit…