The American flag — proudly known as the Stars and Stripes — is more than a banner of colors stitched together. It is a living symbol of rebellion, unity, and the sovereignty of the people. It was never originally the flag of a government, but of a movement; not a mark of officialdom, but of revolution.
Having evolved from the Continental Union Flag, its stripes — with their roots in the "rebellious stripes" of the Sons of Liberty — represent resistance to abusive power, a stand against imperial overreach, and a declaration that legitimate authority flows from the consent of the governed. In this light, the proliferation of the “Thin Blue Line” version of the American flag is not merely a modification of a unique American symbol; it is a mutilation of the flag’s fabric and its meaning. It transforms a people’s flag into a government’s flag, in direct contradiction to its foundational ethos.
The Stars and Stripes emerged during the crucible of the American Revolution. Designed amid a bloody struggle for independence, it represented the collective identity of thirteen colonies rising up against one of the most powerful empires in history. The original flag was not created by a centralized government — such a government did not yet exist, as America (as we know it) was then a collection of colonies (and after the Revolutionary War a collection of sovereign, independent states). Instead, it was adopted by the people, by militias and rebels, by a population seeking liberty and self-determination. The flag signaled not only unity, but defiance. It did not mark a loyalist institution; it flew over encampments of dissenters, over ships that defied royal decrees, and on the battlefields where ordinary citizens staked their lives against authoritarian control.
Its thirteen stripes were not decorative — they were declarations. Each one symbolized a rebellious colony, a place where people had thrown off the chains of monarchy in favor of sovereignty and self-governance. These were rebellious stripes in the most literal sense.
Symbols like the flag derive power from their universality and the principles they are understood to represent. The American flag, when flown in its proper form, represents a nation of laws, a land of liberties and rights defended by man but inherited from God, and the primacy of the people over the state. It is not merely a symbol of bureaucratic jurisdiction or a political claim to territory — it is a promise of principles.
That is why the “Thin Blue Line” version of the flag strikes such a discordant note. Rendered in black and white with a single blue stripe replacing one of the original red ones, this variation is often presented as a tribute to law enforcement. But in doing so, it makes several grave symbolic missteps. First, it appropriates and alters a shared American symbol for a narrow institutional allegiance. Second, it exalts an arm of the state — the police — over the population it is meant to serve. Third, it introduces a political undercurrent that conflicts with the flag’s historical roots in civil resistance and anti-authoritarianism.
The adoption of the “Thin Blue Line” flag has not occurred in a vacuum. It has often been wielded in opposition to movements criticizing police violence or advocating for systemic reform — movements that, ironically, resemble the spirit of protest and accountability that gave rise to the American flag in the first place. To fly the “Thin Blue Line” flag is not just to honor police — it is, in many contexts, a political statement that elevates state force above civilian scrutiny and betrays the very meaning of the Stars and Stripes.
Where the original flag stood for a people rising up against oppressive authority, the “Thin Blue Line” flag often functions as a defense of authority against popular protest — a defense of the kind of authority that systematically encroaches upon the principles articulated in America’s founding documents and represented by the Stars and Stripes. This inversion should trouble anyone who values the spirit of revolution and liberty on which the United States were founded. It changes the flag from a people's standard into a state emblem. It thereby ceases to be a symbol of all Americans and righteous disobedience, to instead become a banner of thoughtless obedience and allegiance to a specific government institution — and an abusive one at that.
True patriotism involves not a charitable submission to authority but a critical love of country — the kind that seeks to protect liberty by holding power to account. Blind reverence for institutions, especially those with the authority to use force, can easily slip into idolatry. The Founders understood this. They feared standing armies, unchecked executive power, and unaccountable police forces. That’s why the Constitution and the Bill of Rights exist — to restrain government, not to sanctify it.
When the American flag is altered to exalt state power, it loses its soul. It no longer reminds us of our right to dissent, our duty to speak out, and our heritage as rebels against tyranny. Instead, it becomes a badge of conformity, submission, and misplaced loyalty.
The Stars and Stripes must not be surrendered to any one ideology, party, or profession — least of all to an arm of state enforcement. It belongs to the people. It was never meant to be a symbol of the government, but a reminder of the source of true power in a land of freedom and bravery: the citizen.
To fly the flag in its true form is to honor the rebellious spirit that birthed a country of liberty and God-given rights. To alter it in ways that exalt state power over the people is not just a misuse of symbolism; it is a betrayal of the very principles the flag was meant to represent.
Let us remember that the American flag, in its original and unaltered form, flies not just because the wind moves it. It flies for the movements of every person who dares to stand, speak, and demand justice. It is not the flag of authority. It is the flag of resistance, the flag of our fathers, and it is ours; and it is the flag of our future if we keep it the way.
Comments
Post a Comment